Get troops out now…
Out of Afghanistan, that is.
One thing you can be sure of is that if Iraq weren’t an isssue today it would be Afghanistan that Democrats would be calling a lost war and a failure.
BERLIN: An opposition party has called for the withdrawal of German troops from Afghanistan after three soldiers were killed in a suicide attack, but Chancellor Angela Merkel said that the international community was determined to make the difficult reconstruction process a success and that German soldiers would remain in the country. ~iht.com
Remember when the ‘occupation’ at the end of WWII was a failure?
BAD AROLSEN, Germany — Looking back at the first weeks after World War II, a French lieutenant named Henri Francois-Poncet despaired at ever fulfilling his mission to establish the fate of French inmates of the Bergen-Belsen concentration camp.
For the living skeletons who survived the Nazi terror, the Displaced Persons camp set up two miles away offered little relief from misery.
People still died at the rate of 1,000 to 1,500 a day. Corpses were stacked in front of barracks, to be carted away by captured SS guards. “Bodies frequently remained for several days in the huts, the other inmates being too weak to carry them out,” Francois-Poncet wrote in a report for the Allied Military Government.
Did the allies even plan for what came after the war?
A bleak picture springs with stark immediacy from typewritten reports by the Allied officers, found in the massive archive of the International Tracing Service in the central German town of Bad Arolsen. The Associated Press has been given extensive access to the archive on condition that identities of victims and refugees are protected.
Far from scenes of joyful liberation that should have greeted the end of Nazi oppression, the files reveal desperation, loss and confusion, and overwhelmed and often insensitive military authorities.
Many had nowhere to go, their families among the 6 million Jews consumed in the Holocaust, their homes destroyed or handed out to new occupants. Those who wanted to get to Palestine were shut out by a British ban on Jewish immigration to the Israeli state-in-waiting.
“Owing to ill treatment by the Germans, most DPs have a distrust and fear of the Allied authorities,” said a September 1945 report signed by British Lt. Col. C.C. Allan. “Many DPs have sunk into complete apathy regarding their future.”
Liberated concentration camps were transformed into DP camps. Food was still scarce — often just coffee and wet black bread — and medical care was insufficient, said a report written for President Harry Truman.
Inmates were kept under armed guard to maintain order. They still wore their old striped, pajama-like concentration-camp-issue uniforms and slept in the same drafty barracks through a bitter winter.
Compounding their misery, they could watch through barbed wire fences and see German villagers living normal lives. In some places, those villagers were forced to tour the camps and help with the burials or at least face up to what their Fuehrer had wrought. But it was scant comfort to the victims.
“As things stand now, we appear to be treating the Jews as the Nazis treated them, except that we do not exterminate them,” wrote presidential envoy Earl G. Harrison in his famously quoted report to Truman after visiting that summer.  ~usatoday.com
Eric -
Great post. Thanks for reminding us that sometimes it takes time to clean up real messes. I suspect you could find similar pieces from Japan after Hiroshima and Nagasaki.
I wonder what the news was like in Dresden and Berlin from the civilian populations after the fire bombing and the house to house fight to take Berlin. Looking at some of the ‘before’ and ‘after’ photos of Berlin and then photos of the place just 20 years later in the 60’s one wonders if they’re pics of the same place.
There’s a reason that we have ‘old sayings’ and it’s because they have a basis in truth. Thus, ‘It’s always darkest before the dawn’, while not universally true, is true often enough to have been immortalized via that statement. Considering the GWOT, it’s dark and may get darker yet but dawn is coming and will arrive if we’ll give it time.
Blue Collar Muse